Hockey Stick “Hokum” & “Consensus”

The “Hockey Stick” Drives Conservatives Crazy

The Wall Street Journey (my favorite newspaper) and its Editorial Page (my least favorite editorials) are showing their strange schism again. Friday’s (7.14.06) second editorial was headlined “Hockey Stick Hokum.” Whoo boy, what a piece o’weak thinking. What weak evidence. What strange rationalizations.

Basically, the Fox-ites in print denied the current state of paleoclimate research in favor of the old, anecdote-based thinking about what’s been happening with global temperature changes over the past thousand years. They attack the original analysis that created the “hockey stick” graph (showing things have been heating up fast in the last century) by excerpting a new report commissioned by the House Energy Committee. The work was done by statisticians, not – heaven forbid – climatologists. Here are the graphics the WSJ editors used:

The top graph is what we’ve had in our textbooks for decades, based on little more than historical tracts. The second graph is the original “hockey stick.”

Here’s the latest hockey stick from the June 30 Science Magazine and The National Research Council, based on state-of-the-art temperature proxy analysis:



The Journal editors seem unaware of this or the continuing critique and fine tuning of the original hockey stick data by the world’s top climatologists. IN FACT, they accept the statisticians' looney position in the new report that the “consensus” (their quotes) about the current warming is some form of “group think” among climate scientists who “passionately believe in their thesis.” Not really a consensus at all, they say, but some kind of high-schoolish “mutual admiration society” among 98% of all climatologists.

Well, WSJ editorialists, you never let the facts jostle the Journal Editorial Page lockstep with the hydrocarbon crowd on anything implying the need for less greenhouse gas emissions. Just another high-schoolish in-crowd thing?

[Read the Science Magazine piece yourself at http://www.sciencemag.org/]


Comments

CapitalistImperialistPig said…
Good points. I liked the fact that you included the three versions of the graphs.
10:14 PM
Joe said…
I think an even better debunking of the hockey stick is here at climate audit:

http://www.climateaudit.org/?p=747#more-747

the author of this site is the guy that debunked the orginal hockeystick.
.....
You can scoff at the historical record, but a set of proxies that doesn't in any way match what happened in historical times (eg hudson river frozen in 1776, or vinyards in england and poland during the middle ages) is not very valid to me.
4:53 PM
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Scooter Duff's Theory of Cosmology [A work in progress]

Image
 [Olde Duff Gets Seriouser] SUPERMASSIVE BLACK HOLES  ARE MOSTLY PRIMORDIAL  DARK MATTER [Draft 8/19/2023] THE BIG NEWS.. ..Is from the James Webb Space Telescope. There were furiously active galaxies very soon after the Big Bang, not that long after the first generation stars happened. This implies supermassive black holes at the centers of the new galaxies.  The question, "how did these giant black holes get there so early?" seems not quite answered by the two main contenders, "Giant dust collapse," and "Many stellar black holes consolidating." Thus I decided to toss this hat into the ring: At the big bang, and dark matter was the first matter of any kind to form (perhaps during the mysterious “inflation” event -- my personal theory).  It’s mutual gravitational attraction and lack of interaction to any electromagnetic force allowed it to exist and start to coalesce, even in the heat of the BB, long before baryonic matter could.  There was a vast quantity
Read more

Rick and Morty

Image
A Millenial Hit Olde Folks Don't Know About Are you over 50? Have you ever heard about "Rick and Morty?" I thought not. There is a "cell" of younger people who love the show and say extravagant things about its wonderfulness. In these times when prior punditry had it we would be unified by some mysterious power in the Internet, there are more and more cells of people, unified within their cells, but isolated from most of the other cells of special interests*, tastes and proclivities.  The U.S. looks more like a pomegranate than a cantaloupe - to push the fruit/melon analogy to its extreme. I will dream up a graphic one of these days. USA, USA! society in fruit form. ANYHOO... I watched Rick and Morty at my millennial son's suggestion, and I LOVE IT. Eccentric old genius and non-genius grandson as the lead characters (faintly Back to the Future -esque) + sci-fi + Simpsons sensibilities +  intelligent satire + over-the-top imaginative creators
Read more

An Informational Present

Image
I TOLD YOU ABOUT THIS SIX YEARS AGO (Surely you remember ?)  ...And in those six years, multiple research projects have affirmed and reaffirmed that SENOLYTICS is a big deal. The science of senolytics: how a new pill could spell the end of ageing                                    * I'm reminded of this by a well-researched article in The Guardian , a newspaper I respect. Aside from that hyperbolic, click-bait-ish headline, it's a fair summary of the state of knowledge on the subject. In brief: Certain drugs and several supplements help the body get rid of senescent cells, "zombie cells" that don't die after they quit doing their thing and just hang around spitting out inflammatory chemicals that damage various organs, joints, and brain cells. The senolytic agents augment apoptosis , nature's way of killing off the senescent cells. When those senescent cells are gone, things start improving measurably (see the mouse with the young look in the Guardian piece.)
Read more